Oh I'm a sucker for kidnap stories (yes, I have admitted it out loud!). I'd love to see both boys get taken (for whatever reason) and Dean cares/comforts a distressed young Sam whilst in captivity. Bonus points for Sam being hurt during their ordeal - but nothing too malicious. Just good old fashioned protective!Dean and scared - but trying to be brave!Sam. :)

(oooh - is that too much for a comment fic? I have to get the hang of this...)